Adopting an Older Cat vs. a Kitten: What You Need to Know

27

Are you thinking of adopting a cat? Whether you’re a first-time cat owner or a seasoned cat parent, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to adopt an adult cat or a playful kitten. Many people believe adopting an older cat is harder, but is it? We’re here to tell you that both choices have their unique challenges and rewards, but it can be a very different experience depending on what you choose.

Join us as we explore the world of feline companionship from both ends of the age spectrum and answer the age-old question: Is it better to adopt a kitten or an older cat? Keep reading to learn more. 

Choosing Between an Older Cat and a Kitten

Before we dive into the pros and cons, let’s talk about the fundamental decision of choosing between an adult cat and a kitten. Your choice should depend on various factors, including your lifestyle, preferences, and expectations.

Older, or “middle-aged” cats are typically defined as cats aged seven years and above. They often come with a sense of wisdom and calmness – and they’re usually litter box trained. If you live in a more settled and predictable environment and don’t have the time and energy for a hyperactive kitten, an older cat might be the right choice for you.

Kittens, on the other hand, are full of playfulness and curiosity. If you’re looking for a pet that you can train from a young age and prefer an energetic, entertaining addition to the family, a kitten could be an ideal fit.

Adult cats ages 1-6 years old can swing to either side of this spectrum, Young adult cats are capable of being as playful and curious as kittens or as sage and snuggly as seniors.

Should I Adopt a Kitten or an Adult Cat?

Is It a Good Idea to Adopt an Older Cat? 

Adopting an older cat can be a wonderful choice if you want to expand your fur family. Older cats often find themselves in shelters, overlooked in favor of kittens, and in need of a loving home. There are several advantages to adopting an older cat, including a more predictable temperament, established habits, and a lower likelihood of destructive behavior compared to kittens who are still learning.

Older cats can be a great match for busy individuals or families as well since they tend to be more relaxed and require less constant attention. Ultimately, we think that adopting an older cat can be an incredibly rewarding experience. After all, you’re providing a kitty with a comfortable and loving home all the way through – one they otherwise might not have had. 

What Are the Pros and Cons of Adopting an Older Cat?

Now, let’s dive deeper into the pros and cons of adopting an older cat. 

Pros:

• Lower Energy Level: One of the primary benefits of adopting an older cat is their (potentially) lower energy levels. Depending on the age you get them, they could be well past the stage of incessant running, climbing, and exploring, which can be a relief if you prefer a more relaxed and less destructive pet.
• Established Personality: Older cats already have a well-defined personality, so you’ll know exactly what you’re getting. This makes it easier to find a cat whose temperament aligns with your lifestyle.
• Independence: Adult cats are often more self-sufficient. They don’t typically require constant supervision or playtime like kittens and are content lounging around the house.
• Potential for Less Training: Older cats typically come litter-trained and might even have some basic training in place. This can be a time-saver compared to the commitment of teaching a kitten the ropes.
• Saving a Life: Older cats are often overlooked in shelters, so adopting one means giving a loving home to a cat that might not have another chance.

Cons:

• Unknown Past Experiences: Even if the cat was an owner-surrender with a known history, it’s impossible to know everything that cat experienced before coming to you. Poor past experiences with people, other animals, or other environmental stimuli could have lingering effects on their personalities.
• Might Not Be Good With Dogs or Other Cats: Kittens definitely have an advantage when it comes to introductions to dogs and other cats. While it can be done, this process may take a little longer to get everyone on the same page. Learn how to introduce a new cat to other cats and dogs.
• Health Issues: Cats may develop health issues with age. While not all adult or senior cats have health problems, it’s a possibility that you need to be prepared for; both emotionally and financially.
• Less Time Together: Since older cats aren’t as young as kittens, you may have less time to spend with your feline friend. The good news, however, is that cats can live up to 20+ years old.
• Attachment to Previous Owner: Some older cats may have a strong attachment to their previous owners and their routines, making the transition to a new home challenging. Many adult cats don’t handle big transitions well, so you’ll need patience and understanding as you help your adult kitty adjust. 

All in all, adopting an older cat is a wonderful choice if you’re seeking a more low-key, low-maintenance companion with an established personality. However, it’s not uncommon to be concerned about getting them settled into their new life or unknown health issues.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Adopting a Kitten? 

So, what are the advantages and disadvantages of adopting a kitten? Let’s talk about that. 

Pros:

• Playful Energy: Kittens are bundles of energy and playfulness, making them a perfect fit for active households, families with children, or anyone who enjoys interactive play. One thing’s for sure – you’ll never be bored with a kitten in your home!
• Moldable Behavior: Kittens are blank slates. The younger you adopt, the greater the opportunity you have to shape their behavior and train them according to your preferences. This can be extremely rewarding if you enjoy teaching and bonding with your pets.
• Longevity of Companionship: Adopting a kitten means you’ll likely have many years together, offering the potential for a deep, long-lasting bond. You won’t have to worry about saying goodbye too early, and you’ll have plenty of opportunities to become the best of friends. 
• Growing Up Together: There’s something magical about watching your kitten grow into a full-fledged cat. You’ll be there for every milestone as they grow into themself and become a mature cat. 

Cons:

• High Energy Level: A kitten’s boundless energy can be overwhelming and destructive if not channeled properly. Expect your furniture to become a playground, and your curtains to double as climbing walls for a period of time.
• Constant Supervision and Training: Kittens require patience, consistency, and time for training. If you’re looking for a more independent pet, a kitten may not be the right choice.
• Unknown Personality: Kittens are a fun mystery box, and their personalities may not fully reveal themselves until they reach adulthood. This means you might end up with a cat that doesn’t quite fit your expectations.
• Need for Socialization: Socialization is crucial for kittens, so if you’re adopting a single kitten, you’ll need to dedicate time to ensure they grow up to be well-adjusted and sociable adults.
• Longer Lifespan Commitment: While it’s a pro for some, the long lifespan of a kitten is a commitment that should be carefully considered. Remember, they can live up to 20 years!

In summary, adopting a kitten is an excellent choice if you’re ready to invest time and energy into training, play, and bonding. It’s a commitment that can result in a rewarding, lifelong friendship. However, it does come with the challenges of dealing with a high-energy furball.

Are you thinking of adopting a playful kitten? Prepare for their energy with simple and fun cat enrichment ideas.

What Is the Best Cat Age to Adopt? 

So, which age is the best? The answer to this question is going to be different for everyone. The best cat age for adoption depends on your specific circumstances and preferences.

In general, we recommend that you adopt an older cat if you prefer a more settled and predictable pet, have a calm household or busy lifestyle, and want a cat with an established personality. For example, if you’re away at work a lot and can’t adequately supervise a new kitty, we highly suggest adopting an adult cat. 

However, if you have an active household and have the time and patience for a high-energy, playful companion, a kitten might be the best fit! This is especially true if you enjoy training and shaping a cat’s behavior and want a long-term commitment with your feline friend.

Pro tip: Help your new cat feel extra special by creating an epic cat room just for them.

Do Older Cats Adjust to New Owners?

Now, let’s address a common concern: Can older cats adjust to new owners? The answer is a resounding YES! While some cats can struggle through transitions, with the right patience and care, your new older cat can adjust well to his or her new home. Regardless of age, cats can form new attachments and bonds, provided they are given time, love, and reassurance. 

We highly recommend using bedding or items from their previous home to make the transition more comfortable. This is because these items can provide a familiar, calming scent. Moreover, if you have other pets, introduce them slowly and under supervision. This helps prevent territorial issues and eases the process of integration. More on that next. 

How Do You Acclimate a Senior Cat to a New Home? 

Acclimating a senior cat to a new home can be a smooth process if you follow certain steps. Start by creating a safe space that’s solely theirs. Set up a quiet room with all the necessities – a litter box, food, water, and cozy bedding. This will be your cat’s safe haven during the initial transition.

If you have other pets, it’s important to slowly and methodically introduce them to one another. This involves feeding them on either side of a closed door and allowing them to smell each other’s presence. After this goes well, gradually shift to feeding them on either side of a see-through barrier, like a screen or a baby gate. After many consecutive positive interactions, you can allow your cat to explore the rest of the house at their own pace. You can also allow your resident pet to explore your new cat’s space. Don’t rush your new family member, though. Let them decide when they’re ready to venture out and meet their new housemates. 

Furthermore, be sure to spend quality time with your new senior cat. Grooming, petting, and play can help build trust and create a strong bond. Try to maintain a consistent schedule for feeding and playtime, which can be extremely reassuring to cats amid a transition.

Ultimately, be patient and understanding of your cat’s needs. They might have quirks, fears, or habits that stem from their previous home, and it’s important to learn just as much about them as they’re learning about you.

Suggested reading: Understanding how to slowly and methodically introduce two cats is crucial for creating a harmonious household.

Finding Your Purr-fect Companion with Age in Mind

The choice between adopting an older cat and a kitten boils down to your individual preferences, lifestyle, and what you’re looking for in a feline companion. If you opt for an older cat, you’ll gain a steady, affectionate, and often low-maintenance companion. Just be prepared for potential health issues and a shorter time together.

On the other hand, kittens offer boundless energy. They offer the thrill of training and shaping a young mind and the promise of a long-term bond. However, they require a lot of dedication and patience. 

Nevertheless, both older cats and kittens can bring immeasurable joy and companionship to your life. Remember, age is just a number. The love and affection you’ll receive from your feline friend are timeless, regardless of whether they’re young or old.

Would you adopt an older cat? Tell us in the comments below!